site stats
Welcome, register | help | log in

Medical Blogging: Debating a Devil's Advocate

Featured in:

Anyone who has been following The Medical Blog Network knows that we see blogging in the future of the medical practice (Physician Blogging: How to Get Results Worthy of Time & Effort).

With so many excellent medical blogs in existence it is easy to forget how far blogging is from the healthcare mainstream. A recent "flight interview" from The Diva Marketing Blog helps put things in perspective.

Toby is marketing blog consultant who sat on a plane next to a cardiologist who registered a strong dislike of all bloggy things:

When he learned that I was doing work in the blog the space, his immediate reaction was to tell me blogs were a waste of time ... nothing more than a bunch of rant opinions and oh by the way, people are getting fired for blogging and colleges are now demanding that students hand over their blogs to them. And who has time to write those things anyway forget reading them. Much too busy.

....

Said the doc, what would I write about? Why would I want to do that? All sorts of things, said I. Information about new happenings in the field, how to cope better, a little about you and your staff. And your patients can comment back to you. Since there are lots of docs and people have a choice who they can go to this would give you a competitive advantage. People would really appreciate who you are and understand what makes you different and special.

Sidebar: The good physician looked at me like I gone off the deep end. If he were a shrink I'm betting he would have made a referral before we deboarded.

I don't want to give them that information. There's too much on the internet already, the doc declared. Great opportunity to make sure they have correct information, I replied. But they don't need to know all that, he proclaimed. It would only confuse them. Besides there are not too many physicians, in fact there are not enough. And I'm too busy now. I don't need any more patients.

The old school doc volleyed a last remark, "I don't practice medicine that way". My volley back, "Perhaps you need to change the way you practice medicine. If I were you I'd keep on eye on blogs".

What to say here? Nice to be in a (sub-)specialty with a shortage and be practicing long enough to not worry about getting more patients. But even then should you really count out the competition?

What about the younger docs trying to establish themselves? What about primary care physicians dealing with more widespread and more general problems? Finally, attracting new patients aside, how about increasing efficiency (and profitability) of serving existing ones?

No doubt, blogging is not for every doctor and this practice is still nascent. But smart docs who care about their reputation will turn it to their benefit and get on the bandwagon early.

Nobody would say that keeping a curriculum vitae (CV) is a waste of time. But blogs is a "live" representation of a medical professional, selling them on the Internet 24/7. The new watchword is Blog-folio.

Once enough early adopters are onboard, a non-participation penalty will develop gradually. Especially as consumers move beyond looking up their conditions online and start relying on Internet to research and select doctors. Who would not want to take control of their reputation?

So watch out for healthcare consumers and purchasers. They will be key to broader acceptance of open media in healthcare.

Trackbacks (2)

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://trusted.md/trackback/8208
from HealthCareVox on Tue, 03/21/2006 - 10:38am

Last week, Toby Bloomberg posted an interesting story about her experience with a cardiologist traveling to the American College of Cardiology annual meeting on her blog, Diva Marketing Blog.  The physician was curious about what Bloomberg did for a

from The Healthcare Information Systems Blog on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 1:45am

HealthVoices.com is the premier medical blog network and aggregator, that organizes user-generated medical content by easy-to-find categories. Unprecedented consumer access to

Comments (6)

Submitted by TraumaOne on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 8:49am.

While blogging to help a Physician develop their practice or get in touch with their patients are good reasons to blog, I think there is a reason that may be more important.  There is something about the process of writing and publishing a blog that helps develop and strengthen our thoughts and ideas.  Writing and publishing was once the exclusive domain of those who had the talent for writing and were publishable.  Blogging changed all that.  While it may lower the quality of what gets "published" it also brings more people into the creative process of writing.

http://the-workshop.blogspot.com/2006/03/writing-creative-catalyst.html

Submitted by pegadoc (not verified) on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 11:15am.

I guess there are lots of reasons to blog.

Blogging for business, to entice patients to your practice.  I don't do that.

Blogging for education, to dispense even more medical info.  I don't do that either.

My reasons are more like TraumaOne's above.  I blog to develop my writing skills and to tell my stories and share my thoughts.

Peg

Submitted by hippocrates on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 11:28am.

Terry & Peg,

Your comments prove your ideas! A writer, no matter how accomplished, always misses something. A larger group can better develop and test ideas in real-time through blogs. BUT, as you do this you are likely to find your professional reputation enhanced anyways. As if you get research papers published.

This does complement my original post nicely, but its main point was about getting the "mainstream" docs on board. Not everyone is as forward thinking as you (yet)!

Would you think of good ways to address the concerns of the doc from the post? How would you respond to him?

Submitted by Dr. Rob Lamberts on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 11:56am.

Getting information from a Blog is entirely different than getting it from a peer-reviewed site.  It is the back-and-forth discussion that is stimulating and educational.  We won't debate whether or not a certain type of medication is indicated for a disease - we can look that up - but the "art" side of medicine is much better gotten from colleagues.  We don't have time to sit around and talk with like-minded physicians (or non-physicians, for that matter), but we can find a community of like-minded professionals online.  So discussions about how we handle things in the exam room, how we interpret contradictory scientific articles, or what is the best way to run a practice like a business are best handled in the Blog community. 

There is so much of what we do that is very much determined by opinion and style.  These areas are prime for us to be discussing with our colleagues.  I don't run to a Blog to get the use of anticonvulsants for bipolar disorder and which meds to choose, I go to UpToDate.com.  I do, however, like to discuss my personal experiences in these areas with other clinicians who have had experience in the area.  Why do we as physicians need to be "islands" - having to re-learn the lessons others could help us with.  The main thing Blogging offers is community.  Community is a powerful tool if used properly.  It is not a substitute for education, but it puts education into the proper context.

Rob

Augusta, GA

For other writings, check out

http://robsoddblog.blogspot.com/

Submitted by Toby - Diva Marketing (not verified) on Mon, 03/20/2006 - 6:36pm.

Thanks for the shout out. It was great to read the comments of your visitors. Rob from Augusta, a neighbor (I'm in Atlanta), made an important point when he mentioned the community aspect of blogs. That's one that I forgot to mention to the good doc. Peer-to-peer blogs are becoming an important resource and as Rob mentioned, sounding board.

If any of your readers would like some basic blog 101 information, checkout a webinar that  I did that was targeted to the healthcare industry. It's free with registration. July 27 - Blogs in Healthcare - Healthy Hype? http://www.healthvoices.com/blog/hippocrates/2006/03/19/medical_blogging_debating_a_devils_advocate

Keep up your good work on The Medical Blog Network!

Submitted by pegadoc (not verified) on Sat, 03/25/2006 - 5:42am.

Toby, Hippocrates and others - you might be interested in this article in the British Medical Assoc. Journal: BMA Article

Post new comment

[?]
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
[?]
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.

User login

make my day make my day again